The True Story Behind Wild Idea That Jaws Might Establish Girl Discovered Almost Beheaded on the Seaside


The “Girl within the Dunes” was bare and decaying — her head virtually decapitated, each wrists lopped off — by the point she was found lifeless in July 1974 in a cluster of timber close to Race Level Seaside in Provincetown, Massachusetts.

She was mendacity face-down on a inexperienced towel. A blue bandana had been tucked beneath her head, which had been bashed in, together with a pair of Wrangler blue denims, “folded up like a pillow.”

On the finish of every arm, the place the girl’s fingers ought to have been, had been piles of pine needles.

Regardless of her grotesque state, whoever killed the girl had left her physique in a serene scene just some dozen ft from the sand roads the place individuals normally got here to discover the coast. The realm was marked with blood, however authorities suspected the girl had been slain some place else days earlier, if not weeks.


“She was undoubtedly posed there ,” recollects Warren Tobias, retired performing police chief in Provincetown. “She was mendacity out on a seaside towel as if she was sunbathing.”

In absence of the girl’s actual identification, she was nicknamed for the the place the place she was discovered. However, even with the development of DNA know-how, her identification and that of her killer have by no means been confirmed.

“After 44 years we nonetheless don’t have that reply,” says Tobias, who has been concerned with the case, as an investigator and extra not too long ago as a civilian, for many years.

The girl’s dying stays a thriller — and a magnet for numerous theories about who could possibly be accountable. (Some even speculate that the infamous South Boston mobster James “Whitey” Bulger, convicted in myriad different murders, had one thing to do with it.)

Now the case is again within the highlight because of writer Joe Hill, son of horror novelist Stephen King.

HIll’s speculation concerning the woman, which he first detailed in an August 2015 weblog put up, has not too long ago gained nationwide consideration, partly due to the podcast Inside Jaws, which delves into the making of Steven Spielberg’s 1975 blockbuster.

His idea? Earlier than she died, the Girl within the Dunes might have appeared as an additional within the movie, a couple of rogue shark consuming his means via the waters round Martha’s Winery in Massachusetts.

Particularly, Hill highlighted a second about 54 minutes and a couple of seconds into the movie throughout a crowd sequence set on the Fourth of July, when he noticed an additional — a match, young-looking girl with brunette hair sporting a blue bandana — who bore a “startling resemblance” to a composite sketch of the girl herself.

He questioned, “What if the younger homicide sufferer nobody has ever been capable of determine has been seen by a whole lot of hundreds of thousands of individuals in a beloved summer time traditional and so they didn’t even know they had been her?”

“What if,” he wrote in 2015, “the ghost of the Girl of the Dunes haunts JAWS?”

In that very same put up, Hill additionally acknowledged a number of points together with his “on the market” idea, reminiscent of the additional not sporting the identical kind of Wranglers discovered with the girl.

What’s extra, he famous, blue bandanas had been worn by six different ladies within the following sequence within the film.

Nonetheless, manufacturing on Jaws had attracted quite a lot of native curiosity and filming was comparatively near the place the girl’s physique was finally discovered (about 100 miles) and occurred not too lengthy earlier than.

• Need to sustain with the most recent crime protection? Click on right here to get breaking crime information, ongoing trial protection and particulars of intriguing unsolved circumstances within the True Crime E-newsletter.

Drawing on his authorial roots, Hill wrote, “It could be no shock in any respect if a woman summering on the Cape determined to take a couple of days to discover the Winery… particularly with the added bait of superstar to attract her in.”

Later, in response to Hill’s weblog put up, he talked to an FBI agent he knew about his concept. The agent, he wrote, instructed him: “You understand, it is perhaps price going ahead together with your idea. There is perhaps one thing in it. Odder concepts have cracked colder circumstances.”

Hill stated it was only a hunch, and a weird one — besides.

“My factor is writing ghost tales,” he instructed the Washington Put up this week. “I can’t inform if that is my creativeness simply doing the factor that it at all times does or if there’s really one thing there.”

Talking with PEOPLE, the case’s lead investigator, Provincetown police Detective Meredith Okay. Lobur, declined to enter element about her work however says, “Something that generates curiosity is at all times good.” (A prosecutor’s spokeswoman was equally succinct, telling PEOPLE: “If any proof surfaces it should definitely be checked out.”)

Detective Loburs says, “We comply with any lead and any idea we’ll comply with up on. If any of your readers have any info, I comply with up on every part.”

Hill agrees. He instructed the Put up, “There are individuals alive at present who had been in that shot in Jaws and know they’re in that shot.”

“Two astonishing issues occurred on Cape Cod in the summertime of 1974,” he continued. “One is that Steven Spielberg filmed Jaws, and different is that somebody murdered this girl within the dunes exterior Provincetown and acquired away with it. Something that stirs individuals’s recollections might doubtlessly be productive.”

The case has perplexed detectives for many years. Her physique discovered by a younger lady strolling her beagle, the girl’s fingers had been severed in an effort to forestall her identification.

Her hair, reddish-brown, was worn in a ponytail and she or he weighed between 140 and 150 lbs., standing between 5-foot-6-inches and 5-foot-Eight-inches tall.

Tobias, the retired police chief, says she was in her mid to late 20s. Notably, she had about $10,000 price of gold crowns in her mouth and the dental work she had had completed was within the “New York type.”

By the years authorities have exhumed the girl’s stays twice, as DNA know-how has progressed, and reconstructions have been completed to attempt to seize what she regarded like earlier than she was slain, Tobias says.

A radar drone has been used. Mob ties had been probed, motorbike gangs had been investigated. Psychics have even been contacted, purely out of desperation.

Tobias says a Maryland assassin even confessed, about 20 years in the past, however police didn’t imagine him — his story didn’t add up.

Tobias, who joined the Provincetown police the identical summer time the girl was discovered lifeless, later took over the case in 1989 and labored on it till retiring in 2009. He’s nonetheless concerned as a civilian, he says, and is actively engaged on promising angles, however he declines to elaborate.

Requested concerning the attainable eventualities that led to the girl’s dying, Tobias says he might “discuss for hours.”

He’s appreciative of the curiosity Hill’s idea brings to the case: “I’ve thought a very long time that’s what it will take, quite a lot of publicity, for someone to lastly come ahead with some type of info.”

However he’s personally skeptical it holds the reply to the thriller.

“Do I feel it’s her? I don’t know. Is there a resemblance? Yeah, I feel some, however it was the ’70s. I imply a whole lot of hundreds of younger ladies dressed that means — blue denims and bandanas, with their hair down. Is it attainable? Positive. Is it possible? Most likely not. Simply the mathematical odds.”

Studio data might not be useful. The Put up experiences that, many years in the past, extras weren’t as meticulously tracked by the productions who employed them and an Leisure Weekly reporter was unsuccessful in gaining extra info from the Common archives.

The movie’s casting director has additionally handed away, in response to Esquire.

Tobias thinks that maybe the girl “wasn’t from this county and from some place else fully, reduce off information from right here. Maybe she was an orphan and perhaps she didn’t have any household.”

“So many issues about it you’ll suppose we might have the ability to remedy it and determine her,” he says. “I can inform you that the Provincetown Police Division just isn’t giving up on this.”

Anybody with details about the case is urged to contact Detective Meredith Okay. Lobur at 508-487-1212 or

Supply hyperlink


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here